How to Write a Winning RFP Response (Step-by-Step)
A comprehensive guide to crafting RFP responses that stand out. From requirement analysis to final submission, master every step of the process.
Writing RFP responses is part compliance exercise, part storytelling. The best proposals nail both: they answer every question the buyer asked while making a compelling case for why you're the right choice.
This guide walks through the entire process, from the moment the RFP lands in your inbox to clicking submit.
Initial Assessment (Day 1)
Download and organize everything
RFPs come with baggage: the main document, appendices, pricing templates, required forms, amendments. Before you read a single word, create a dedicated folder and organize everything. Check the issuer's website for any Q&A documents or amendments posted after the initial release.
Mark your calendar
These dates matter:
When you must submit clarifying questions
When the buyer responds to all questions
Final due date (note the timezone!)
When they expect to announce the winner
Make the go/no-go call
Not every RFP deserves your time. Before committing resources, ask yourself:
- •Do you meet the mandatory requirements?
- •Is the contract value worth the effort?
- •Do you have a realistic shot at winning?
- •Does this align with your strategic goals?
See our Go/No-Go Decision Framework for a structured approach.
Deep Analysis (Days 2-3)
Extract every requirement
This is where proposals succeed or fail. You need to find every requirement in the document:
Time saver: Tools like RFP Matrix extract requirements automatically from RFP documents. What takes hours manually takes minutes with AI.
Build your compliance matrix
A compliance matrix maps each requirement to your response. Create a spreadsheet tracking:
| Column | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Requirement ID | Section number from RFP |
| Requirement text | Exact wording from document |
| Compliance status | Compliant / Partial / Non-compliant |
| Response location | Where you address it in your response |
| Owner | Who's writing this section |
Flag your knowledge gaps
Mark requirements where you need:
- • Input from subject matter experts
- • Clarification from the buyer (submit as questions before deadline)
- • Approval from leadership (pricing, contract terms)
- • Technical verification ("can we actually do this?")
Strategy and Planning (Days 4-5)
Define your win themes
Win themes are 3-5 differentiators you'll weave throughout the response. Good win themes are:
Outline each section
Before anyone writes anything, outline every section:
- • Key points to cover
- • Requirements addressed
- • Win themes incorporated
- • Supporting evidence (stats, case studies)
- • Page allocation based on evaluation weight
Assign writers and reviewers
For complex RFPs, you'll need a team:
Writing (Days 6-12)
Write the executive summary last
It's the most-read section, but you can't summarize what doesn't exist yet. Write it after everything else is done.
Lead with benefits, not features
"Our platform uses AES-256 encryption."
"Your sensitive data is protected by the same encryption standard used by the U.S. government, ensuring compliance with your security requirements."
Always answer the implicit question: "So what? Why does this matter to me?"
Use STAR for examples
When including case studies or examples:
Be specific with numbers
Vague claims get ignored. Specific numbers get remembered:
Address weaknesses proactively
If you have obvious gaps (less experience, higher price, smaller team), address them directly with mitigation strategies. Evaluators will notice the gap anyway. Showing you've thought about it builds trust.
Review and Polish (Days 13-14)
Compliance check
Walk through your compliance matrix and verify:
- • Every "shall" requirement has a clear response
- • Response locations are correctly noted
- • No requirements have been missed
- • All claims are accurate and defensible
Formatting check
RFPs often have strict formatting requirements. Check:
Red team review
Have someone who wasn't involved read the proposal as if they were the evaluator. Ask them:
- • What are our top 3 differentiators?
- • What concerns would you have about selecting us?
- • Is anything confusing or unclear?
- • What's missing?
Final proofread
Read the entire document aloud. This catches errors that silent reading misses. Watch for:
- • Consistent terminology throughout
- • Correct client name everywhere (seriously, check this)
- • Pricing that matches your pricing sheet
- • Dates and timelines that make sense
Submission (Day 15)
Submit early
Never submit at the last minute. Systems crash, uploads fail, time zones cause confusion. Aim to submit at least 4 hours before the deadline.
Confirm receipt
After submitting:
- • Save the confirmation email or number
- • Screenshot the submission portal
- • If no confirmation received, contact the buyer immediately
Mistakes That Kill RFP Responses
What Winning Teams Do Differently
They're selective
They pursue fewer RFPs but invest more in each one.
They start early
The best responses begin before the RFP is issued, through relationship building.
They learn from losses
They request debriefs and continuously improve their process.
And increasingly, they use tools to handle the tedious parts (extracting requirements, generating first drafts, tracking compliance) so humans can focus on strategy and storytelling.
Less time extracting, more time winning
RFP Matrix uses AI to extract requirements and generate draft responses in minutes. Free up your team to focus on the parts that actually win deals.
Get startedReady to respond to RFPs 10x faster?
RFP Matrix uses AI to extract requirements and generate draft responses automatically.
Get StartedFound this helpful? Share it with your team.